Categories
Review 2026
BestGuide Score
4.3
out of 5
Each company is evaluated across five criteria. Scores are weighted and combined into a single BestGuide Score out of 5. See how we rate the brands.
Key Takeaway
Uncommon Goods earns a BestGuide Expert Score of 4.3/5.0, a top destination for unique, hard-to-find gifts. Founded in 1999 and a Certified B Corporation, it is an online marketplace built around creatively designed, often handmade and sustainable products from independent makers, spanning home, kitchen, jewelry, and personalized items across a wide range of prices. Its "Better to Give" program lets you direct a donation to a nonprofit at checkout. It scores well on Reputation and Services (both 90/100); the trade-offs are longer lead times on made-to-order items and prices that can run higher than mass-market gifts.
Best For: Shoppers who want original, handmade, or personalized gifts from independent makers and care about supporting a values-driven, sustainable marketplace.
Uncommon Goods is an online marketplace for unique, creatively designed gifts, founded in 1999 and based in Brooklyn, New York. A Certified B Corporation, it curates products from independent artists and small makers, with a strong emphasis on handmade, personalized, and sustainably made items across home, kitchen, jewelry, and more. Its "Better to Give" program lets customers direct a donation to a nonprofit at checkout. In this Uncommon Goods review, we break down its selection, values, shipping, and value, and how it compares to the best gift companies.
Founded
1999
Certification
B Corp
Headquarters
Brooklyn, NY
Shop by occasion, recipient, interest, or price using filters designed to help you find an original gift rather than a generic one.
Many products are handmade, personalized, or made from recycled materials by independent makers, so the catalog skews toward items you will not find in big-box stores.
Where offered, add names, dates, or custom text to personalized items. These are often made to order, which affects shipping time.
Through the Better to Give program, you can direct a donation to a nonprofit of your choice at checkout at no extra cost to you.
Complete your order for US delivery. Confirm the item's ship-by estimate, since handmade and made-to-order pieces can take longer.
Uncommon Goods fits shoppers who want original over ordinary.
It is not ideal for last-minute gifts with tight deadlines, shoppers chasing the lowest price, or anyone who needs fast or international shipping.
Unique, Curated Selection
The catalog centers on creatively designed, often handmade products from independent makers, so gifts feel original rather than mass-produced.
Better to Give Program
At checkout you can direct a donation to a nonprofit you choose at no added cost, tying each purchase to a cause.
Personalized Gifts
Many items can be customized with names, dates, or messages, which are typically made to order.
Wide Price Range
Products span affordable to premium, so you can find a gift for most budgets and occasions.
Values-Driven and Sustainable
As a Certified B Corporation, it emphasizes fair pay for makers and sustainable materials, including recycled and upcycled products.
Helpful Browsing Tools
Filters by recipient, occasion, interest, and price make it easier to find a specific, thoughtful gift.
Pros
Cons
Uncommon Goods is a legitimate, well-established online marketplace founded in 1999 and based in Brooklyn, New York. It is a Certified B Corporation, a verified standard for social and environmental performance, and it works with independent artists and small makers, with a Better to Give program that has directed donations to nonprofits over many years. What to know: because much of the catalog is handmade or made to order, shipping can take longer than mass-market retailers, prices can be higher, and some customers report occasional delivery or service friction. Confirm ship-by estimates for time-sensitive gifts. Its longevity, certification, and maker network give it strong credibility.
Uncommon Goods earns an Expert Score of 4.3/5.0, one of the best places to find a gift you will not see everywhere else. As a Certified B Corporation operating since 1999, it curates unique, creatively designed products, many handmade or made from recycled materials, from independent artists and small makers, and its "Better to Give" program donates to a nonprofit you choose at checkout. Selection and values are its strengths, spanning home, kitchen, jewelry, and personalized gifts across a wide price range. The trade-offs are practical: made-to-order and artisan items can take longer to ship, prices can run higher than big-box gifts, and shipping is mainly US-based. For a distinctive, meaningful gift, it is an easy recommendation. You can compare it with the best gift companies first.
BestGuide rates Uncommon Goods 4.3/5.0, praising its unique, maker-driven selection and B Corp values, with slower shipping on handmade items and higher prices the main caveats.
Yes if you want an original, meaningful gift and can plan ahead. Its curated, often handmade selection and Better to Give program set it apart from big-box gift sites.
Yes. It is a Certified B Corporation founded in 1999 and based in Brooklyn, New York, with a long track record as a gift marketplace.
At checkout you can direct a donation to a nonprofit you choose at no extra cost, so each order supports a cause.
Yes. Many items can be personalized with names, dates, or messages, though these are usually made to order and take longer to ship.
Standard items ship reasonably quickly, but handmade and made-to-order pieces take longer, so check the ship-by estimate for time-sensitive gifts.
Prices span affordable to premium. Artisan and handmade items can cost more than mass-market gifts, reflecting maker pay and materials.
Find your match
Answer a few questions and we'll point you to the right service. No sign-up needed.
