Categories
Review 2026
Each company is evaluated across five criteria. Scores are weighted and combined into a single BestGuide Score out of 5. See how we rate the brands.
Key Takeaway
Dr. Marty Pets earns a BestGuide Expert Score of 4.3/5.0, a high-quality freeze-dried raw pet food with a premium price and some fine print. Its strengths are Reputation, Services, and Scalability (90 to 95/100): a brand founded by veterinarian Dr. Marty Goldstein, real whole-food ingredients, formulas for different life stages, and wide availability. The drag is Transparency (70/100): aggressive marketing, an auto-subscription enrollment that has drawn many complaints, and one of the highest price-per-pound tags in dog food. The food itself has never been recalled and earns solid marks, if you can manage the checkout and cost.
Best For: Owners who want vet-formulated, freeze-dried raw nutrition with real whole-food ingredients and are willing to pay a premium and manage the subscription carefully.
Not sure if Dr. Marty Pets is the right fit? Compare the alternatives
Dr. Marty Pets is a premium pet nutrition brand founded in 2017 by Dr. Marty Goldstein, an integrative veterinarian with more than 45 years of experience who earned his DVM from Cornell in 1973. The company makes freeze-dried raw dog and cat food built on whole-food ingredients, alongside supplements and treats. Its flagship dog formula, Nature's Blend, and cat line, Nature's Feast, are designed as species-appropriate, minimally processed diets. In this Dr. Marty Pets review, we break down the food, ingredients, cost, and the subscription catches to watch, and how it compares to the best pet food brands.
Founded
2017
Founder
Dr. Marty Goldstein, DVM
Type
Freeze-dried raw
See If You Qualify
Visit the site to get started in less than a minute.
Pick a dog formula such as Nature's Blend, or the Nature's Feast cat line, with options for food sensitivities, seniors, puppies, and small breeds.
You can buy a single bag or enroll in a recurring subscription. Read the checkout carefully, since the auto-subscription enrollment is the most common source of complaints.
The food is freeze-dried raw, so you add warm water to rehydrate it before serving, which restores texture and makes portions go further.
Mix Dr. Marty in with your pet's current food over several days to avoid digestive upset, following the feeding guide for your pet's weight.
The brand also sells vet-formulated supplements, such as a probiotic blend and a joint-support formula, plus treats and dental chews to round out a routine.
Dr. Marty fits owners who prioritize ingredient quality over price.
It is not for budget-focused owners, anyone who wants a wide variety of flavors and formats, or shoppers who prefer to avoid subscriptions and high price-per-pound.
Freeze-Dried Raw Nutrition
The food is minimally processed and rehydrated with water at serving time, aiming to keep more of the nutrition of a raw diet with the convenience of shelf-stable food.
Whole-Food Ingredients
Recipes use identifiable meats like turkey, beef, salmon, and duck, plus organ meats and fruits and vegetables, rather than generic meals or fillers.
Formulas by Life Stage and Need
Options cover food-sensitive pets, seniors, puppies, and small breeds, so you can match the formula to your pet.
Vet-Founded Brand
Founder Dr. Marty Goldstein is a licensed integrative veterinarian with decades of experience, which anchors the brand's health-first positioning.
Supplements and Treats
Beyond food, the brand offers a probiotic blend, a joint-support supplement, high-protein treats, and dental chews.
No Recall History
Through 2026, Dr. Marty food has never been subject to an FDA or manufacturer recall, a meaningful safety signal in pet food.
Pros
Cons
Dr. Marty Pets is a legitimate pet nutrition brand founded in 2017 by Dr. Marty Goldstein, a licensed integrative veterinarian with more than 45 years of experience. Its freeze-dried raw food uses real, identifiable whole-food ingredients and has never been subject to an FDA or manufacturer recall through 2026, which are strong quality and safety signals. What to watch: the concerns are commercial rather than food-safety. The brand uses aggressive marketing and an auto-subscription enrollment that has generated hundreds of documented complaints, and it carries a premium price. Review the checkout carefully, confirm whether you are enrolling in a subscription, and keep records if you need to cancel.
Dr. Marty Pets earns an Expert Score of 4.3/5.0. On quality, it delivers: freeze-dried raw dog and cat food built on real, identifiable whole-food ingredients, backed by founder and integrative veterinarian Dr. Marty Goldstein, with no FDA or manufacturer recall in its history. Formulas cover sensitivities, seniors, puppies, and small breeds, and the range extends into supplements and treats. What holds the score below our usual bar is not the food but the business side: emotionally charged marketing, an auto-subscription enrollment that has generated many complaints, and a price per pound among the highest on the market. If you want premium raw nutrition and will watch the checkout and manage your subscription, it is a strong option. You can compare it with the best pet food brands first.
BestGuide rates Dr. Marty 4.3/5.0, praising its whole-food ingredients, vet founder, and clean recall record, while flagging its premium price and subscription practices.
Yes for owners who want minimally processed raw nutrition and will pay a premium. If price or subscriptions are a concern, weigh other high-quality brands first.
Dr. Marty Goldstein is a licensed integrative veterinarian with more than 45 years of experience who founded the brand in 2017.
No. Through 2026, Dr. Marty food has never been subject to an FDA or manufacturer recall.
It is freeze-dried raw food made with whole-food ingredients, which costs more to produce, and it carries one of the highest price-per-pound tags in the category.
Yes. Checkout can enroll you in a recurring subscription, which is the most common complaint. Review the order carefully and confirm your subscription settings.
You rehydrate it with warm water before serving and transition gradually from your pet's current food over several days, following the weight-based feeding guide.
Find your match
Answer a few questions and we'll point you to the right service. No sign-up needed.