On this page14 sections
- Ratings and complaints
- Evermore Pet Food vs. competitors
- Pricing
- Step by step
- Evermore Pet Food legitimacy and licensing
- Evermore cost
- What you get: recipes, sourcing and cooking
- Evermore Pet Food Review: Human-Grade, Gently Cooked Nutrition
- Complaints and what to watch for
- Cancellation, refunds and subscriptions
- Is Evermore right for puppies, kittens and cats?
- What customers say
- Alternatives
- FAQ
Evermore Pet Food is a legitimate company that has sold cooked dog food since 2009 and added cat food in 2024. You pay by the pouch, $13.50 to $14 a pound for dog food and $12.50 for a 12 oz cat pouch, with no meal plan or box to commit to. We found no FDA recalls, and its BBB file shows an A+ rating with no complaints in three years, but there are almost no independent customer reviews to judge it by. The main catch: once an order ships, Evermore won't refund food your pet simply doesn't like, so start with a small order.
- Dog food price
- $13.50 a 1 lb pouch for Beef or Chicken, $14 for Lamb or Turkey, as listed October 20262
- Cat food price
- $12.50 a 12 oz pouch, Beef or Turkey, as listed October 20262
- Shipping
- Free on subscription orders of 16 or more items; ships frozen with dry ice Monday to Thursday, 1 to 2 days in transit for most of the US4
- Refunds
- No refunds once shipped, or if your pet dislikes the food; thawed, damaged or wrong items are replaced or refunded3
- Nutrition standard
- Dog recipes formulated for adult maintenance (not puppies); cat recipes for all life stages, per AAFCO, NRC and FEDIAF guidelines3
- Where it's made
- A USDA and FDA inspected human food kitchen in Southern California; every batch lab tested before sale3
- Company
- Evermore Pet Food, Inc., women-owned and independent, founded 2009; mailing address in Olivebridge, New York5
- Recalls
- None found in FDA enforcement records as of October 202610
Pros
- Sourcing spelled out recipe by recipe, with named ranch partners
- Every batch lab tested for pathogens and nutrients before release
- No FDA recalls found since 2009
- Buy as few as 4 pouches, no plan required
- Cat recipes are complete for all life stages, including kittens
Cons
- Among the priciest fresh foods per pound
- No refund if your pet dislikes the food
- Dog recipes aren't complete for puppies
- Free shipping only on subscription orders of 16 or more items
- No veterinary nutritionist on staff
Best for: Owners of adult dogs or cats who want cooked food with documented high-welfare sourcing and will pay more per pound for it.
Skip it if: You have a puppy, are on a tight budget, or want a money-back guarantee for a picky eater.
Evermore Pet Food vs. competitors
| Company | Price | How you buy | If your pet won't eat it | BBB |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Evermore | $13.50 to $14 a 1 lb dog pouch | By the pouch, one-time or subscription | No refund once shipped | A+, accredited |
| Ollie | Full Fresh plan from $1.57 a meal | Subscription plan | Not published | B, not accredited |
| JustFoodForDogs | Chicken & Rice about $11 an 18 oz pack | Subscription or one-time | Full refund on first order within 30 days | F, not accredited |
| Spot & Tango | Fresh plans from $2 a day | Subscription plan | 14-day refund on first order | A+, accredited |
Evermore Pet Food pricing at a glance
Evermore prices, as listed October 20262
| Product | Size | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beef Recipe for dogs | 1 lb pouch | $13.50 | Dog recipes range from 435 to 556 kcal a pound |
| Chicken Recipe for dogs | 1 lb pouch | $13.50 | See dog food page |
| Lamb Recipe for dogs (grain-free) | 1 lb pouch | $14.00 | See dog food page |
| Turkey Recipe for dogs (grain-free) | 1 lb pouch | $14.00 | See dog food page |
| Beef Recipe for cats | 12 oz pouch | $12.50 | 478 kcal a pouch |
| Turkey Recipe for cats | 12 oz pouch | $12.50 | 350 kcal a pouch |
| Evermorsels freeze-dried treats | 2 to 3 oz bag | $17.99 to $20.99 | Single ingredient: salmon or beef kidney |
Shipping is free on subscription orders of 16 or more items; Evermore says that saves $25 or more an order, so smaller orders pay frozen shipping. The smallest order is 4 pouches. Your daily cost depends on your pet's calorie needs; Evermore's feeding calculator or free consult gives an amount.
Evermore Pet Food, step by step
Work out how much to feed
Use the feeding calculator or book a free consult. Evermore can be a full diet or a topper.
Build an order
Pick pouches by recipe, one-time or as a subscription at the interval you choose. Orders start at 4 pouches.
Get it frozen
Orders ship Monday to Thursday with dry ice in recyclable cold boxes. Order by Tuesday 5pm Eastern to ship that week.
Thaw and serve
Thaw in the fridge overnight. Use a thawed pouch within about a week and an opened one within about 5 days.
Manage or cancel
Change or cancel a subscription in the online portal. You get an email 3 days before each charge.
Evermore Pet Food legitimacy and licensing
Yes. Evermore Pet Food, Inc. was founded in 2009 by Hanna Mandelbaum and Alison Blumberg and is still independent and women-owned. It describes itself as a B Corp. Food is cooked in a USDA and FDA inspected human food kitchen in Southern California, and Evermore says it lab tests every batch for Salmonella, E. coli, Listeria and other pathogens before release.
Its BBB profile shows an A+ rating, accreditation since May 2019 and no complaints in the last three years. We found no Evermore recalls in FDA enforcement records, and Dog Food Advisor rates the fresh line 5 stars. The gap is customer feedback: Trustpilot has no reviews and BBB has none either, so most praise you’ll see comes from Evermore’s own site, vets it quotes, and pet food reviewers.
Evermore cost
Evermore sells by the pouch rather than by a meal plan. Dog food is $13.50 a pound for Beef or Chicken and $14 for Lamb or Turkey. Cat food is $12.50 for a 12 oz pouch. Freeze-dried Evermorsels treats are $17.99 to $20.99 a bag.
Shipping is free only on subscription orders of 16 or more items, and Evermore says that saves $25 or more per order, so small or one-time orders cost noticeably more. Feeding a large dog a full Evermore diet can mean a pound or more a day, so many owners use it as a topper or partial diet, which Evermore supports.
What you get: recipes, sourcing and cooking
There are four dog recipes (Beef, Chicken, Lamb and Turkey; Lamb and Turkey are grain-free) and two cat recipes (Beef and Turkey). Evermore says it uses 100% grass-fed regenerative beef and lamb, pastured chicken and eggs, organic free-range turkey and organic produce, and lists its ranch partners on its site and labels.
Food is sealed in pouches, cooked sous vide to 165°F and frozen. Liquid in the pouch, sometimes red from beef or berries, is normal broth. Dog recipes are formulated for adult maintenance; cat recipes are for all life stages and include added clam broth for moisture.
Key Takeaway: Evermore Pet Food (Expert Score: 4.5/5.0)
Evermore Pet Food earns an Expert Score of 4.5/5.0 from BestGuide, ranking it as a top choice for pet owners seeking human-grade, gently cooked food with radical sourcing transparency. Founded in 2009, this women-owned B Corp has maintained a clean recall record and offers free personalized nutrition consults.
Evermore Pet Food Review: Human-Grade, Gently Cooked Nutrition
Evermore Pet Food earns an Expert Score of 4.5/5.0 from BestGuide, placing it among the most transparent and ethically sourced pet food companies in the market. This Evermore Pet Food review examines the brand’s strengths, limitations, and how it compares to competitors like JustFoodForDogs and Ollie.
Founded in 2009, Evermore is a women-owned B Corp that produces gently cooked, human-grade meals for dogs and cats. The company uses 100% grass-fed beef and lamb, pastured chicken, organic free-range turkey, and organic produce, and it is Global Animal Partnership (G.A.P.) welfare-certified. All food is cooked sous-vide in a USDA/FDA-inspected kitchen, then frozen and shipped directly to customers. Evermore excels in transparency and sourcing, but it is a small operation with premium pricing.
Compare Evermore Pet Food with other top-rated pet food companies to see how it stacks up.
What customers say about Evermore Pet Food
Recurring themes across the review sites and complaint records listed above, not individual quotes.
Common praise
- Detailed sourcing, with named ranches and full nutrient profiles published
- Quick, personal customer service and free consults
- Pets that are picky or have sensitive stomachs eating it well
- Long track record with no recalls found
Common complaints
- High price per pound compared with mass-market fresh food
- Small range: four dog recipes, two cat recipes
- No taste guarantee or refund once an order ships
- Very few independent reviews to check
Complaints and what to watch for
Formal complaints are rare: BBB shows none in three years. The tradeoffs come from Evermore’s policies. It won’t refund an order because your pet doesn’t like it, and it can’t change an order on the day it ships. If food arrives fully thawed and warmer than fridge temperature, or a pouch is damaged or the wrong recipe arrives, it will replace or refund; send photos.
To avoid problems, start with the 4-pouch minimum, keep your subscription address updated in the subscription portal (not just your profile), and watch for the renewal email 3 days before each charge.
Cancellation, refunds and subscriptions
You can cancel an order only before it ships; contact Evermore right away by phone at (718) 596-6788 on weekdays 9am to 5pm Eastern or by email. Subscriptions are managed in an online portal where you can change items, timing or cancel. Evermore sends a reminder 3 days before charging your card.
Is Evermore right for puppies, kittens and cats?
Evermore says its dog recipes fall a little short of puppy levels for calcium and phosphorus, so it is not complete for puppies without supplements. Ask your vet before feeding it to a growing dog. The cat recipes are formulated for all life stages and are suitable for kittens. Evermore has no veterinary nutritionist on staff but says it consults outside experts.
Alternatives to Evermore Pet Food
- JustFoodForDogs Better if you want a money-back first order and recipes that passed AAFCO feeding trials. Read review
- Ollie Better if you want a portioned subscription plan with a lower price per meal. Read review
- Spot & Tango Better if you need puppy-safe recipes or a refund if your dog won't eat the first order. Read review
- Home cooking with a vet nutritionist's recipe The DIY route if you want full control; ask your vet or a board-certified veterinary nutritionist for a balanced recipe.
Evermore Pet Food reviews
Written by readers, read by our moderators, never edited by the company.
No reader reviews yet. If you have used Evermore Pet Food, yours will be the first.
Write a reviewHow do I know I can trust these reviews about Evermore Pet Food?
- Every reviewer confirms an email address before a review can publish.
- Our moderators read every review before it publishes.
- Companies can respond publicly but can never edit, hide or remove a review.
- Paying BestGuide never changes the reader rating or which reviews publish.
Frequently asked questions
Can you trust Evermore Pet Food?
Yes. It has been in business since 2009, holds an A+ BBB rating with no complaints in three years, and we found no FDA recalls. Independent customer reviews are scarce, though.
How much does Evermore dog food cost?
$13.50 for a 1 lb pouch of Beef or Chicken and $14 for Lamb or Turkey, as listed October 2026. Shipping is free on subscription orders of 16 or more items.
Has Evermore ever had a recall?
We found no Evermore recalls in FDA enforcement records, and Dog Food Advisor notes none. Evermore says every batch is lab tested for pathogens before it's sold.
Does Evermore make cat food?
Yes. Beef and Turkey recipes for cats launched in 2024, sold in 12 oz pouches for $12.50. They are formulated for all life stages, so kittens can eat them.
Can puppies eat Evermore?
Not as a complete diet. Evermore says its dog recipes fall a little short of puppy calcium and phosphorus levels and suggests a supplement plan; check with your vet first.
Is Evermore raw?
No. It's fully cooked sous vide to 165°F and frozen. Red liquid in the pouch is broth from cooked meat or berries, not blood.
Can I get a refund if my dog doesn't like it?
No. Evermore won't refund food your pet dislikes or cancel an order after it ships. It will replace or refund thawed, damaged or incorrect items.
Where is Evermore food made?
In a family-owned, USDA and FDA inspected human food kitchen in Southern California that follows HACCP food safety rules.
How long does Evermore last?
Frozen pouches are dated for 18 months. Once thawed in the fridge, open within about a week, and use an opened pouch within about 5 days.
Where can I buy Evermore?
Online at evermorepetfood.com for frozen delivery, or at independent pet stores listed in its store locator.
Sources (12)
Facts on this page come from company websites, government agencies and regulators, checked on the dates shown. Editorial standards
- Evermore Pet Food: Home (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Shop online (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: FAQs (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Shipping (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Contact (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Who we are (accessed October 12, 2026)
- BBB: Evermore Pet Food, Inc. (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Trustpilot: evermorepetfood.com (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Dog Food Advisor: Evermore Fresh (accessed October 12, 2026)
- openFDA: Food enforcement reports search for Evermore (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Cat food (accessed October 12, 2026)
- Evermore Pet Food: Dog food (accessed October 12, 2026)
BestGuide is free to use. Some companies we review pay us when you visit their site or contact them through us. Compensation may influence which companies we feature and their order. It doesn't change what our reviews say. Advertising disclosure